Wednesday, April 2, 2025

IWSG and the falsity of safe places

 It is the first Wednesday of the month and so that means another meeting of the IWSG or for anyone new (is there really ever anybody new?) the Insecure Writers Support Group, where those of us who use pen and keyboard gather to laugh and cry about the whole thing. If you are interested here is a link to the signup page - IWSG

Purpose: To share and encourage. Writers can express doubts and concerns without fear of appearing foolish or weak. Those who have been through the fire can offer assistance and guidance. It’s a safe haven for insecure writers of all kinds!

The awesome co-hosts for the April 2 posting of the IWSG are Jennifer Lane, L Diane Wolfe, Jenni Enzor, and Natalie Aguirre!

This month's question is 

What fantasy character would you like to fight, go on a quest with, or have a beer/glass of wine with?

This question is a tough one. I think most of the characters in fiction are fantasy characters but I'm willing to play the game. So . . . I'd like to hang out with Robin Hood and his merry band. I'd like to help him figure out ways to outwit the greedy men led by Prince John and the Sherriff of Nottingham, who have taken advantage of King Richard being away on a pilgrimage to plunder the land. I'd like to live in the forest with people who understand that it is better to fight for what is right than submit to tyranny. And let us not forget his band is merry! Why are they merry? Because they are not pretending that nothing is happening - they are taking action. And they balance out their righteous quest with eating and drinking and playing music in a beautiful sylvan place. Also, I've also wanted to learn how to use a bow and arrow. I'm a Sagittarius after all.

painting by Newel Convers Wyeth

WARNING! - the following is an opinion on so-called safe places and is not under the banner of the IWSG

 I was conflicted writing this piece. Why? Because the IWSG has cautioned us to make sure our writing under their banner is about writing and not about the world burning down etc. . . Why is writing about fantasy characters okay then? What has that to do with the practice of writing? Reading yes, writing no. Don't get me wrong please. I love the IWSG - been a part of it from the beginning, but I'm most recently allergic to the notion that talking about what is happening in the world, even in a non-partisan way is unsafe. As a psychotherapist who has dealt with many people who suffer from PTSD I can tell you what feels unsafe to me - people pretending nothing is happening when something clearly is. Also, I write about what is affecting me - whether it is in my poetry, my essays or my fiction. My fiction is about issues like the environment, indigenous oppression, human trafficking and so on. These are directly related to what I'm sensing and reacting to in my environment. So, I may be cautioned to stick to some lane or another, but I'm afraid that, like Robin Hood, the Doctor, Bilbo Baggins, Harry Potter and Buffy the Vampire Slayer, I will not.

 


6 comments:

L. Diane Wolfe said...

I think discussing is fine, just not words or acts of hate, like the idiots burning Teslas.

I'd like to hang out with the animated Robin Hood - he was one cool fox!

Natalie Aguirre said...

I really like that Robin Hood gave to the poor. Hopefully if you follow Diane's advice, you'll be okay.

Margot Kinberg said...

I agree, Jan. I think there are times when we need to talk about what's going on in the world. It all has a real impact on us, and we can't really take care of ourselves without knowing what's affecting us. At least, that's how I see it. And I love your choice for fictional character you'd like to hang out with if you could.

Alex J. Cavanaugh said...

Open discussions are fine. One-sided rants of vile hate are not and don't help anyone. (We had two of those last month.) So the topic isn't off the table, people just need to be civil.

Nick Wilford said...

Can't go far wrong with the redistribution of wealth idea that Robin Hood has, especially nowadays. I also agree it's important for writers to not be muzzled and reflect real issues to keep them in the conversation.

C.D. Gallant-King said...

There are no safe spaces, not anymore. No one is safe when your government can snatch people up under the cover over darkness, can abuse and change the rights of human beings indiscriminately, can threaten other sovereign nations hoping for an excuse to go to war.

Telling WRITERS they're not allowed to talk about that is the dumbest thing I've ever heard.